Why Not Shielding? Exploring Alternative Solutions
3. Twisted Pairs vs. Shielded Cables
You might be wondering, “Why not just use shielded cables instead?” Shielded cables have a metallic layer that surrounds the wires, providing excellent EMI protection. And you’re right, shielding is a valid solution, and it’s often used in more critical applications. However, it comes with a few drawbacks.
First, shielded cables are more expensive than twisted pairs. The extra material and manufacturing processes add to the cost. Second, shielded cables are typically bulkier and less flexible. This can make them more difficult to route through tight spaces in a car. Third, shielded cables require proper grounding to be effective. If the shield isn’t properly grounded, it can actually make the EMI situation worse! It can act like an antenna, picking up even more noise.
For many CAN bus applications, twisted pairs provide a good balance between performance, cost, and ease of use. They offer sufficient EMI protection for most automotive environments. Shielding is typically reserved for situations where the EMI is particularly severe or where data integrity is absolutely critical, such as in aerospace or medical applications.
Think of it like choosing between a basic raincoat and a full-on hazmat suit. The raincoat is fine for a light drizzle, but if you’re dealing with toxic chemicals, you’ll need the hazmat suit. Similarly, twisted pairs are often sufficient for everyday automotive use, but shielded cables are necessary for more demanding environments.